Roundhouse Digital Marketing Taylor, TX - Logo

How to Pick an SEO Agency

Philip Ellis • August 12, 2023

Are you looking to improve your website's search engine ranking but don't know where to start? Hiring an SEO company can be a game-changer for small businesses trying to compete in today's digital world. But choosing the right agency can be challenging, especially if you are unfamiliar with the industry's ins and outs. This post will share ten tips for picking a company that aligns with your business goals and delivers results. We will cover everything from understanding the role of an agency to evaluating their experience, expertise, and pricing structure. By the end of this article, you'll have a clear roadmap for selecting an SEO company that fits your business needs.


Understanding the Role of an SEO Agency

SEO agencies play a crucial role in optimizing websites for search engines. With their expertise in digital marketing, they utilize various techniques to improve website rankings and increase organic traffic. These agencies stay updated with the latest Google algorithms and metrics, ensuring that websites are optimized according to the best practices. By hiring an agency, businesses can significantly improve their online presence and reach a wider audience. This allows business owners to focus on other important aspects of their business while the agency handles the technicalities. SEO agencies also provide valuable insights through tools like Google Analytics and Google Search Console, enabling businesses to make data-driven decisions. Their role goes beyond just web design and extends into areas such as conversion rate optimization, social media integration, and UX enhancements. Choosing the right agency is essential for businesses to achieve the best results and align with their specific needs.

Blocks with words on them that have to do with SEO

Why Hiring an Agency is Beneficial

Small businesses often struggle to compete with larger competitors online. That's where hiring an agency can make a huge difference. These agencies have the knowledge and resources to create effective strategies to optimize small business websites for local search. By targeting specific keywords and implementing best practices, SEO agencies help small businesses attract customers in their area.


One of the biggest advantages of hiring an agency is that it is a cost-effective way for small businesses to improve their online visibility and increase customer acquisition. Instead of spending thousands of dollars on traditional advertising methods, investing in SEO can yield long-term results and better ROI. Small businesses can see significant organic traffic and keyword expansion with the right agency, leading to increased revenue.


In today's digital age, having a strong online presence is crucial, and agencies play a vital role in achieving that. They work in tandem with businesses to understand their goals and align their strategies accordingly. By staying up-to-date with SEO latest trends and techniques, agencies ensure that small businesses always use the best practices to improve their rankings on search engines like Google and Bing.


Hiring an agency is a smart investment for small businesses looking to level the playing field and achieve online success.


Identifying Your Goals In Google

Defining your goals is a crucial step before hiring an agency. It sets the foundation for a successful partnership and helps agencies create a customized strategy tailored to your business needs. Common SEO goals include improving keyword rankings and increasing organic traffic. By clearly identifying your SEO goals, you can ensure that you and the agency are aligned regarding expectations and outcomes.


Business Metrics and SEO Strategy

To ensure alignment, the agency you choose should deeply understand your target audience and develop strategies to attract relevant traffic. This means they must understand your industry, the digital marketing landscape, and how SEO fits into the bigger picture. By aligning your business goals with the SEO strategy, you can optimize all marketing channels, including social media, blog, and other digital platforms, to work cohesively towards achieving your objectives.


It's important to have realistic expectations and clearly communicate your key things so the agency can tailor their approach accordingly.


SEO Expertise

When evaluating the experience and expertise of an SEO company, it is crucial to look for a proven track record and extensive industry knowledge. A reputable firm will have a portfolio showcasing successful case studies and results achieved for previous clients. By examining their work, you can gain insight into their capabilities and the effectiveness of their strategies.

Additionally, certifications and recognition in the field can serve as indicators of a company's expertise. These credentials demonstrate their commitment to staying updated with the latest trends and best practices.


Furthermore, choosing a company that specializes in your specific industry or niche is beneficial. This expertise allows for more targeted and effective strategies tailored to your business needs. A deep understanding of your industry enables the SEO company to identify relevant keywords, optimize content, and implement appropriate techniques to improve your website's search engine rankings.


White-Hat Vs. Black-Hat

White hat SEO techniques are essential for building a sustainable online presence. These techniques follow search engine guidelines and prioritize providing value to users. On the other hand, black hat SEO techniques involve manipulative tactics that violate search engine rules. While black hat techniques may yield quick results, they can harm your website's reputation in the long run.

creepy black hat seo guy

It is crucial to work with an agency that follows white-hat SEO practices. Doing so can ensure long-term success and avoid penalties from search engines. White hat SEO techniques focus on organic growth, quality content, and ethical practices. This approach aligns with search engine algorithms and user expectations, improving search rankings and increasing organic traffic.


Choosing the right agency that understands the importance of white hat SEO techniques is key. They will help your website rank higher and establish a trustworthy online presence. So, when picking a company, prioritize agencies that emphasize white hat techniques and are committed to delivering long-term results.


SEO Best Practices

Conducting thorough keyword research and optimizing website content accordingly are key steps in this process. On-page optimization, including proper meta tags and quality backlinks, significantly improves search engine rankings and drives organic traffic to your site. Regular website audits are essential for identifying and resolving any technical issues that may be affecting your SEO performance. By following these best practices, an SEO agency can ensure that your website is properly optimized for search engines and provides a positive user experience.


Budget

When it comes to selecting an agency, budget considerations play a crucial role. Before making a decision, it is important to determine your budget for services. Different agencies may offer various pricing structures and packages, so it's essential to consider the value and expertise they bring rather than solely focusing on the cost. Finding an agency that offers a balance between affordability and quality services is key.


While it's tempting to opt for the cheapest option, it's important to remember that investing in SEO can lead to long-term benefits and a higher return on investment. So, it's worth looking beyond the price tag and considering the long-term value an agency can provide. Finding the right agency that aligns with your budget and meets your needs can ensure that your digital marketing efforts are optimized for success.


Pricing Structure

When it comes to choosing an agency, understanding the pricing structure is crucial. Different agencies offer various pricing models, including monthly retainers or project-based fees. The pricing can be influenced by factors such as the scope of work, competition level, and the agency's expertise. It's important to note that some agencies may provide tiered packages with different levels of service and deliverables. As a business owner, you should take the time to understand what is included in the pricing fully and if there are any additional costs or hidden fees. Having an open and transparent discussion with the agency about its pricing structure ensures that it aligns with your budget and goals. Remember, it's not just about finding the cheapest option but rather the right agency to deliver results within your budget.


Client Testimonials

Client testimonials and case studies play a crucial role in showcasing the expertise and effectiveness of a company. They provide tangible evidence of the company's successful track record and show you the results you can expect from their services. By examining real-life examples of their work, you can gauge their ability to deliver the desired outcomes for your business.


The presence of positive client testimonials and case studies is also a strong indication of the company's reputation and reliability. It instills confidence in their capabilities and gives you the assurance that they can meet your needs effectively. When selecting an agency, it's important to consider these testimonials and case studies as they demonstrate the company's alignment with your goals and their proven track record of delivering results.


By analyzing client testimonials and case studies, you can make an informed decision and choose the right SEO company that aligns with your business objectives and has a history of achieving the best results for its clients.

Seo Consultant with a happy client

Verifying their Track Record

Verifying a company's track record is crucial in making the right decision for your digital marketing needs. I highly recommend checking the company's past performance and results before committing to their services.


Start by looking for success stories and achievements from previous campaigns the company has worked on. This will give you an idea of their capabilities and expertise. Additionally, verifying their track record can be done by checking their rankings and metrics from past projects. This will help you gauge their effectiveness in improving search engine optimization.

Researching the company's track record is an essential step in ensuring that they have a proven track record of achieving results for their clients. Good SEO companies will have actual sales and conversion rate optimization to showcase their success.


Remember to set realistic expectations and understand the key things to look for in the track record while evaluating different agencies. Verifying the track record of an SEO company is a critical part of finding the right agency to align with your business goals.


Relevance of Industry Knowledge

Having industry knowledge is crucial for any agency when it comes to optimizing keywords and creating content that resonates with your target audience. By understanding your industry, they can identify the most relevant keywords that will attract your desired customers.


Additionally, staying updated on the latest trends and algorithms is essential for effective SEO strategies. An SEO company with industry knowledge can implement techniques that align with your niche and ensure that your website is optimized to attract organic traffic. This knowledge also helps them develop content that appeals to your specific market, increasing the likelihood of converting visitors into actual sales. Therefore, choosing an agency with industry expertise is one of the key things to consider to achieve the best results.


How will the SEO Agency Improve Your Rankings?

Improving your website's rankings requires a clear plan and strategy. Look for an agency that focuses on optimizing both on-page and off-page factors. Prioritizing search engine optimization, they should have a track record of improving keyword rankings and increasing organic traffic.


An effective SEO company will develop a customized strategy specifically tailored to your business needs and goals. They should have a clear understanding of your target audience and employ techniques such as keyword research, content optimization, and user experience design to reach them. Look for a comprehensive plan that includes both on-page and off-page optimization.


Agencies should provide regular updates and reports to keep you informed about the progress of your campaign. Transparency is key, so ask how often they will provide these updates. Look for an agency that offers clear and understandable reports and proactive insights and recommendations based on the data. Open communication ensures you stay informed throughout the process.


Long-Term Commitment

Choosing an SEO company with a long-term commitment to your success is essential. Look for a company that focuses on sustainable strategies rather than short-term fixes. Ongoing support and optimization should be part of their services, even after the initial campaign. A good SEO company will prioritize building a strong online presence for your business, using tactics like digital marketing, social media, and search engine optimization. They should also have a comprehensive plan for on-page and off-page optimization, utilizing tools like Google Analytics and Google Search Console to track progress. Remember, a long-term commitment from the right agency ensures continuous growth and improvement.

seo consultant with client

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some warning signs to consider when choosing an SEO company?

    When choosing an SEO company, be cautious of those who guarantee specific rankings or quick results. Avoid companies that use black hat tactics like keyword stuffing or buying backlinks. Look for transparency in their work and strategies, and beware of companies with a history of penalization or low-quality work.

  • How long does it typically take to see results?

    Typically, it takes several months to see significant results from an SEO campaign. The timeline for success varies based on competition, industry, and keyword difficulty. Reputable agencies provide realistic timelines and regular progress updates. Patience and consistent effort are key to a successful campaign.

  • What Happens if You Are Not Satisfied with the Services?

    If you are unsatisfied with the services, it's important to understand the company's policies. Ask about their process for addressing concerns and resolving issues. Clear communication is essential for a successful partnership.

  • Does the SEO Company Understand Your Niche?

    Choosing an SEO company that understands your industry is crucial. Their knowledge allows them to develop a tailored strategy aligned with your business goals. Look for experience working with businesses in your industry, ensuring effective optimization and familiarity with industry-specific keywords and trends.

  • How can I determine if an SEO company is reputable and trustworthy?

    To determine if an SEO company is reputable and trustworthy, look for reviews and testimonials from previous clients. Research the company's experience and track record in the industry. Check if they use ethical and white-hat techniques. Ask for references or case studies to see their past successes.

  • Are there any specific questions I should ask a potential SEO company before hiring them?

    Consider these questions when evaluating an SEO company: What is their industry experience and success rate? How do they plan to improve your website's ranking? Do they follow Google's guidelines and avoid black hat tactics? How often can you expect updates on progress and communication?

Final Thoughts

To ensure your SEO efforts' success, choosing the right SEO company is crucial. Remember, this decision will significantly impact your online visibility and organic traffic. Take the time to evaluate the experience and expertise of the SEO company, ensuring they follow white hat SEO techniques and provide transparent reporting. Consider your budget and review client testimonials and case studies to verify their track record. It's equally important that the SEO company understands your industry and has a tailored strategy for your business. Don't forget to inquire about the frequency of updates and reports. Above all, think about long-term commitment and ensure there is a provision for addressing any dissatisfaction you may have. If you're ready to take your SEO efforts to the next level, get in touch with our team of experts today.

Download

Get Fresh Content From

Roundhouse Digital Marketing

A man wearing a hard hat is working on a roof.
By Philip Ellis April 4, 2025
Learn how roofing companies can get better results from Google Local Service Ads. Boost your ranking, increase leads, and book more roofing jobs with these proven LSA maintenance tips.
Two men are working on the roof of a house.
By Philip Ellis April 2, 2025
Struggling to show up on Google? Discover the top 5 reasons your roofing company isn't ranking—and how to fix them to start getting found by local customers.
Two men are working on the roof of a house.
By Philip Ellis April 1, 2025
Struggling to get leads from your roofing website? Learn the top reasons most roofer websites fail—and how to turn yours into a lead-generating sales machine.
A keyboard , pen , cell phone , and papers on a wooden table.
By Philip Ellis March 21, 2025
Understand the key terms in your monthly marketing reports and discover actionable ways to boost performance through reviews, social posts, call handling, and more.
A man is sitting at a desk holding a sign that says `` how to get my business verified on google ''.
By Philip Ellis February 25, 2025
Verifying your Google Business Profile (GBP) is a crucial step to making your business discoverable on Google Search and Maps . A verified profile allows you to update your business details, interact with customers, and improve your local search rankings. This guide walks you through Google's verification methods , focusing on the video verification process , which is the most commonly required method in 2025. Why Google Business Profile Verification Matters Google requires verification to confirm your business exists and is legitimate . Once verified, you can: ✔️ Show up in local searches on Google Search & Maps ✔️ Manage business details like hours, location, and services ✔️ Respond to customer reviews ✔️ Gain access to performance insights ⚠️ Important: Most businesses will need to complete video verification , but some may qualify for alternative methods. Google Business Profile Verification Methods Google offers several verification methods depending on your business type, location, and profile history. 1. Video Verification (Most Common) Required for most new business profiles or address changes Google requires a real-time, unedited video showing your business location, operations, and proof of ownership. This method is used to prevent fraudulent listings. 2. Instant Verification (Rare) Some businesses that already have verified websites with Google Search Console may qualify for instant verification. This method is uncommon and depends on Google’s internal data. 3. Phone Call Verification (Limited) Some businesses can verify via a phone call to their listed business number . Google provides a code that must be entered in the profile manager. 4. Email Verification (Limited) If eligible, Google sends a verification email to your registered business email. You must enter the code received via email. 🛑 Note: Postcard verification is no longer available as of 2025. How to Verify Your Business with Video Verification Step 1: Start the Verification Process Sign in to Google Business Profile Manager . Select the business you want to verify. Click "Verify Now" and choose video verification if prompted. Follow the on-screen instructions to begin recording. Step 2: Record Your Verification Video Your video must clearly show at least three types of proof : Business Location If you have a storefront : Record the outside of your business , including signage and neighboring buildings. Show any street signs, address plaques, or identifiable surroundings . If you have a service-based business (home office, mobile business, or remote work) : Show your home office, workspace, or storage area for business materials. If mobile, record your work vehicle with branding or business-related items inside . Business Equipment & Operations Show industry-specific tools, equipment, or workstations . If possible, demonstrate work in action (e.g., turning on tools, preparing products). Examples: A plumber might show pipes, fittings, and tools in their van. A landscaper could display mowers, trimmers, and storage. A retail store should showcase shelves, products, and a point-of-sale system. Proof of Business Legitimacy Show business-related documents , such as: Business license, permits, or official paperwork. Utility bills or invoices with your business name and address . If applicable, display your business website, booking system, or customer orders on a screen. Step 3: Submit the Video The video must be recorded live in one continuous take (no edits or cuts). Once recorded, follow the on-screen steps to submit it directly to Google . Google will review the video , which may take several hours or days. You will receive a confirmation email once your business is verified. What to Do After Verification Once verified, your business is officially recognized by Google! You can now: ✔️ Create Google Posts to engage customers. ✔️ Add business hours, photos, and services to improve visibility. ✔️ Reply to reviews and manage customer interactions. ✔️ Optimize your profile to rank higher in Google Search & Maps . 💡 Pro Tip: Keep your profile fully updated and optimized to prevent suspensions or future verification issues. Tips for Successful Verification ✅ Ensure your business details match what’s on your Google Business Profile (Business Name, Address, and Phone Number – "NAP"). ✅ Use steady camera movements —avoid shaky or blurry footage. ✅ Ensure good lighting so all details are visible. ✅ Narration is optional , but explaining what you’re showing can help. ✅ Do NOT edit, trim, or cut the video —Google requires an unedited recording. ✅ If verification fails, Google may request a redo or offer another verification method . Frequently Asked Questions
Show More

About The Author:

a man with a beard wearing a red shirt is smiling in a circle .

Philip Ellis

Founder and CEO, Roundhouse Digital Marketing

My name is Philip and I am a web design and client attraction consultant. I specialize in helping contractors, roofers, home builders, and other local service-based businesses get more views, leads, and sales online.


With over 12 years of experience in the industry, I have the knowledge and skills to create stunning websites and effective digital marketing campaigns that drive results for my clients.

Share by: