Roundhouse Digital Marketing Taylor, TX - Logo

Lead Gen Mastery: Owning Vs. Renting Your Marketing Channels

Philip Ellis • May 21, 2024

Let’s take a minute to talk about all of the OPTIONS you have for getting more customers online. HomeAdvisor, Thumbtack, Angie’sList, Google Ads, Facebook Ads, SEO, Google Business Listing, Craigslist (if that’s even still a thing…) are just a few of the many paths you can take. However, only a couple have proven themselves over time. Let’s quickly go over the pros & cons of each.

Evaluating Popular Lead Sources

HomeAdvisor

  • Pros: You can get “leads” fast.
  • Cons: They are shared leads, low quality, you don’t OWN your marketing channel (HomeAdvisor controls it all, including the price per lead), and you’re not investing long-term into your business. Essentially, you’re just renting someone else’s marketing channel!)

Thumbtack

  • Pros and Cons: Same as HomeAdvisor.

Google Ads

  • Pros: Get website traffic and leads quickly.
  • Cons: You have to pay per click for as long as you want results.

Facebook Ads

  • Pros: Get website traffic quickly.
  • Cons: Leads can be extremely low quality, even fake, and the “buyer intent” is much lower than leads from Google.

Craigslist

Really, do I even need to cover this one??? Let’s leave Craigslist for your Auntie Ethel and people selling their used mattresses.

Google Business Listing

  • Pros: Generates calls like clockwork if ranked on Google properly.
  • Cons: Takes some time to optimize & rank on Google.

Below: A before and after image of one of our client's Google Business ranking reports. In one month we fixed some major visibility issues, and are on track to dominate the area for his service keywords. If you don't understand what you are looking at, watch this video.

SEO (Search Engine Optimization)

  • Pros: Highest quality leads of all lead sources, you OWN the marketing channel (your website), you don’t have to pay per lead, and you can continue to expand your target market reach over time.
  • Cons: Same as Google Business Listing, it can take some time to optimize & rank on Google.


Below: Our clients getting 100+ calls, without having to pay per lead.

The RENTING vs. OWNING Analogy

What’s the picture that’s being painted here? All of these lead sources and marketing channels fall into TWO categories:

  1. Lead sources where you are RENTING someone else’s marketing channel (HomeAdvisor, Thumbtack, Craigslist, etc.)
  2. Lead Sources where you OWN the marketing channel, and it becomes a lead-generating ASSET that you can leverage for years to come (Google Business Listing & SEO).

The best illustration for this difference is “RENTING vs. OWNING”, in regards to real estate. Why would you pay someone rent ($$$$$), making them more money over time, when you could OWN your home, creating and leveraging an ASSET for yourself?


Leveraging SEO for Long-Term Benefits

At Roundhouse Digital Marketing, this is the message we’re constantly preaching. Whenever you decide to utilize SEO to transform your Website & Google presence into an ASSET that you invest in over time, good things happen. You start to generate your own, uber-qualified leads through your website & business listing, you begin to rank your website, which is a long-term growth catalyst for your company, and you’re building a marketing & lead generation asset that YOU own, and NO ONE ELSE (your competitors) have access to! It’s a win-win-win, and you’re constantly investing in your company.


Getting Started

So, are you wanting more information on how to get started? We can hook you up with all of the information you need to get educated on the process. Click this link and book a Free 10-minute marketing strategy call with us! Book A Call Here We can answer any questions you have about how to leverage Google to build a long-term lead generation ASSET using your very own website!

Download

Get Fresh Content From

Roundhouse Digital Marketing

Two men are working on the roof of a house.
By Philip Ellis April 1, 2025
Struggling to get leads from your roofing website? Learn the top reasons most roofer websites fail—and how to turn yours into a lead-generating sales machine.
A keyboard , pen , cell phone , and papers on a wooden table.
By Philip Ellis March 21, 2025
Understand the key terms in your monthly marketing reports and discover actionable ways to boost performance through reviews, social posts, call handling, and more.
A man is sitting at a desk holding a sign that says `` how to get my business verified on google ''.
By Philip Ellis February 25, 2025
Verifying your Google Business Profile (GBP) is a crucial step to making your business discoverable on Google Search and Maps . A verified profile allows you to update your business details, interact with customers, and improve your local search rankings. This guide walks you through Google's verification methods , focusing on the video verification process , which is the most commonly required method in 2025. Why Google Business Profile Verification Matters Google requires verification to confirm your business exists and is legitimate . Once verified, you can: ✔️ Show up in local searches on Google Search & Maps ✔️ Manage business details like hours, location, and services ✔️ Respond to customer reviews ✔️ Gain access to performance insights ⚠️ Important: Most businesses will need to complete video verification , but some may qualify for alternative methods. Google Business Profile Verification Methods Google offers several verification methods depending on your business type, location, and profile history. 1. Video Verification (Most Common) Required for most new business profiles or address changes Google requires a real-time, unedited video showing your business location, operations, and proof of ownership. This method is used to prevent fraudulent listings. 2. Instant Verification (Rare) Some businesses that already have verified websites with Google Search Console may qualify for instant verification. This method is uncommon and depends on Google’s internal data. 3. Phone Call Verification (Limited) Some businesses can verify via a phone call to their listed business number . Google provides a code that must be entered in the profile manager. 4. Email Verification (Limited) If eligible, Google sends a verification email to your registered business email. You must enter the code received via email. 🛑 Note: Postcard verification is no longer available as of 2025. How to Verify Your Business with Video Verification Step 1: Start the Verification Process Sign in to Google Business Profile Manager . Select the business you want to verify. Click "Verify Now" and choose video verification if prompted. Follow the on-screen instructions to begin recording. Step 2: Record Your Verification Video Your video must clearly show at least three types of proof : Business Location If you have a storefront : Record the outside of your business , including signage and neighboring buildings. Show any street signs, address plaques, or identifiable surroundings . If you have a service-based business (home office, mobile business, or remote work) : Show your home office, workspace, or storage area for business materials. If mobile, record your work vehicle with branding or business-related items inside . Business Equipment & Operations Show industry-specific tools, equipment, or workstations . If possible, demonstrate work in action (e.g., turning on tools, preparing products). Examples: A plumber might show pipes, fittings, and tools in their van. A landscaper could display mowers, trimmers, and storage. A retail store should showcase shelves, products, and a point-of-sale system. Proof of Business Legitimacy Show business-related documents , such as: Business license, permits, or official paperwork. Utility bills or invoices with your business name and address . If applicable, display your business website, booking system, or customer orders on a screen. Step 3: Submit the Video The video must be recorded live in one continuous take (no edits or cuts). Once recorded, follow the on-screen steps to submit it directly to Google . Google will review the video , which may take several hours or days. You will receive a confirmation email once your business is verified. What to Do After Verification Once verified, your business is officially recognized by Google! You can now: ✔️ Create Google Posts to engage customers. ✔️ Add business hours, photos, and services to improve visibility. ✔️ Reply to reviews and manage customer interactions. ✔️ Optimize your profile to rank higher in Google Search & Maps . 💡 Pro Tip: Keep your profile fully updated and optimized to prevent suspensions or future verification issues. Tips for Successful Verification ✅ Ensure your business details match what’s on your Google Business Profile (Business Name, Address, and Phone Number – "NAP"). ✅ Use steady camera movements —avoid shaky or blurry footage. ✅ Ensure good lighting so all details are visible. ✅ Narration is optional , but explaining what you’re showing can help. ✅ Do NOT edit, trim, or cut the video —Google requires an unedited recording. ✅ If verification fails, Google may request a redo or offer another verification method . Frequently Asked Questions
A poster for the 2025 social media calendar
By Philip Ellis January 22, 2025
Get your 2025 Social Media Calendar and take the guesswork out of planning! Designed to drive growth and engagement, this easy-to-use calendar helps business owners save time, stay consistent, and connect with their audience effectively.
An electrician working on an outlet on a wall
By Philip Ellis August 28, 2024
Google is rolling out an automated lead crediting system for its Local Services Ads, fundamentally changing how businesses handle unqualified leads. This update, gradually rolling out through August, promises to streamline the lead management process and potentially increase overall credits for advertisers. Key Changes in the GLSA Platform: Automatic Lead Crediting: Google will now automatically identify and credit accounts for low-quality leads, eliminating the need for manual dispute submissions. Increased Overall Credits: While credits for "job type not serviced" and "geo not serviced" leads will be discontinued, Google assures advertisers they'll receive more credits overall through this automated system. Lead Feedback Survey: Advertisers can still provide feedback on individual leads through a new Lead Feedback Survey in their lead inbox, helping Google improve lead quality and occasionally leading to additional credits. What This Means for Your Business: This update simplifies the lead crediting process, potentially saving time and effort for businesses. However, it's crucial to remain vigilant in monitoring your GLSA performance to ensure you're receiving appropriate credits. Here's how we're adapting our strategies: Strategic Feedback Submission: We'll leverage the new Lead Feedback Survey to report any leads that should be credited but weren't caught by Google's automated system. Ongoing Optimization: We'll continue to fine-tune your GLSA campaigns to maximize quality leads and minimize unqualified ones. While Google's update promises a more efficient system, active management of your GLSA campaigns remains crucial. Our team at Roundhouse Digital Marketing is ready to help you adapt to these changes and maximize your return on investment in Google Local Services Ads. Looking for more qualified calls? Reach out to us today and discover how we can help your business thrive.
Show More

About The Author:

a man with a beard wearing a red shirt is smiling in a circle .

Philip Ellis

Founder and CEO, Roundhouse Digital Marketing

My name is Philip and I am a web design and client attraction consultant. I specialize in helping contractors, roofers, home builders, and other local service-based businesses get more views, leads, and sales online.


With over 12 years of experience in the industry, I have the knowledge and skills to create stunning websites and effective digital marketing campaigns that drive results for my clients.

Share by: